East View of St. Cuthberts or West Church of Edinburgh

Category

Library Item

Item no

1116

Title

East view of St. Cuthberts or West Church (Kirk) of Edinburgh

Artist / maker

Skene, James

Date

1827

Size

13 x 22 cm.

Type

Watercolour

Location

Edinburgh and Scottish Collection

James Skene's eastwards view captures the essentially rural aspect of old St Cuthbert's Church or "West Kirk". The position of the church was so overshadowed by Edinburgh castle that for a time the church was also known as St Cuthbert's Under the Castle.

The original St Cuthbert's, first mentioned in a charter of 1126, was demolished in 1772. Regarded as the "Kirk in the Country", its large parish boundary extended as far as Newhaven and Leith. Owing to its position so close to the castle, the church was frequently caught up in cross fire and fighting. It survived the reformation in the 16th century and civil war during the 17th century, but by the 18th century its structure had become increasingly unsafe. On the 27th September 1772, during the course of a Sunday service "part of a seat in one of the galleries gave way with a crash, on which the entire assembled mass rushed to the doors, and in an instant the church was empty"(1). A seemingly small incident re-enforced existing concerns. Demolition work began shortly afterwards.

Skene's watercolour, which is based on earlier views, represents the old, pre 1772 church, as four low lying buildings, surrounding a square spire, some five storeys in height. Immediately to the west of the church, on slightly higher ground is the Knowe, comprising the oldest part of the burial ground. 18th century gravestones survive to this day and include impressive gravestones of prosperous Portsburgh Baillies. To the immediate east of the church, out of sight beneath the lowering bulk of Edinburgh Castle rock, is the Nor'Loch, later drained to make way for Princes Street Gardens. In 1820, James Skene had overall responsibility for supervising the laying out of the gardens.

In 1775, the rambling old kirk was replaced by a huge new "box" like church. Although the uncompromising appearance of the church was tempered by the addition of a steeple in 1789, the 18th century church was demolished in the early 1890s to make way for a new structure designed by Hippolyte Blanc. The steeple and tower of the original building were retained.

(1) Grant, James, Old and New Edinburgh, Edinburgh, 1882, Vol II, 134

Exhibitions with this item

Other views of this item

Related images

Related subjects

Architecture > Architectural features > Spires

Architecture > Architectural features > Weather vanes

Places > Scotland > Edinburgh

Religion > Religious facilities > Protestant churches

Read how our collections have inspired people taking part in events, visits and community groups. Use the slider or navigation arrows to see more responses.

East view of St. Cuthberts or West Church of Edinburgh